Football » English » Simulator Development Feedback

Remarks

By aspher - 08-03-2012 15:28

[MZ]

So what stood out to me so far: 1. Still too many irrational backpasses, if not more than in the current version of the SIM. 2. Heading has not been changed? I'll call your bs, players suddenly head so hard that i'm amazed they can still walk afterwards. Whether this is simply the animation they added, or whether it actually affects the number of goals that will be made by heading, I can't say. 3. Virtually every pass made (using wings tactics) is a long/high ball, which A: results in a pinball machine-like display of the match in 3D, and B: doesn't make any sense at all in some cases where players literally are like 2 meters apart from each other without any defending players in between them, C: only leads to unnesecary loss of the ball as it is more dificult to control and more likely to be intercepted. 4. Way too many shots end up on the crossbar, a weak solution to avoiding a large number of goals. Please add intercepting of the ball and further improve tackling and man-marking to reduce the number of goal-attempts, rather than going for these weaker alternative, mainly graphical solutions. 5. Still, too many obvious scoring chances end up right in the hands of the keeper. Reward a striker for breaking free from his defenders and getting in front of an open goal. Literally, a 2 year old could make some of these scoring opportunities.So what stood out to me so far:
1. Still too many irrational backpasses, if not more than in the current version of the SIM.
2. Heading has not been changed? I'll call your bs, players suddenly head so hard that i'm amazed they can still walk afterwards. Whether this is simply the animation they added, or whether it actually affects the number of goals that will be made by heading, I can't say.
3. Virtually every pass made (using wings tactics) is a long/high ball, which A: results in a pinball machine-like display of the match in 3D, and B: doesn't make any sense at all in some cases where players literally are like 2 meters apart from each other without any defending players in between them, C: only leads to unnesecary loss of the ball as it is more dificult to control and more likely to be intercepted.
4. Way too many shots end up on the crossbar, a weak solution to avoiding a large number of goals. Please add intercepting of the ball and further improve tackling and man-marking to reduce the number of goal-attempts, rather than going for these weaker alternative, mainly graphical solutions.
5. Still, too many obvious scoring chances end up right in the hands of the keeper. Reward a striker for breaking free from his defenders and getting in front of an open goal. Literally, a 2 year old could make some of these scoring opportunities.

 

Page 1

 

Reply

Last Message

Re: Remarks

By aspher - 08-03-2012 20:36

[MZ]

Apologies about .2 Apparently I misinterpreted something and noone ever said nothing had been changed to the heading. Again my apologies. And thanks to Darkline for pointing that out to me.Apologies about .2 Apparently I misinterpreted something and noone ever said nothing had been changed to the heading. Again my apologies. And thanks to Darkline for pointing that out to me.

Re: Remarks

By derekmcc - 09-03-2012 00:26

I agree entirely with points 1 & 5. I still think there are too many cards - I had 6 in my test match ( 1 player sent off) with my tactics set at normal pressing. I like the more powerful headers, so long as players don't start scoring from ridiculious distances.I agree entirely with points 1 & 5. I still think there are too many cards - I had 6 in my test match ( 1 player sent off) with my tactics set at normal pressing. I like the more powerful headers, so long as players don't start scoring from ridiculious distances.

Uuesti: Remarks

By cyrusvk - 09-03-2012 19:13

Have anyone tried both wing tactics and short passes tactics with this beta sim? I have played 2 matches, and it seems to me that as now short passes are very bad choice compared to wings, then with this beta sim short passes are again very good tactic compared to wings. Wing play looks much worse with new sim.Have anyone tried both wing tactics and short passes tactics with this beta sim? I have played 2 matches, and it seems to me that as now short passes are very bad choice compared to wings, then with this beta sim short passes are again very good tactic compared to wings. Wing play looks much worse with new sim.

Re: Remarks

By za_elf - 13-03-2012 08:06

[STEAUA]

i don't like that the strikers try to score from outside the box with their heads. It's not real.i don't like that the strikers try to score from outside the box with their heads. It's not real.

 

Page 1