Football » English » ManagerZone talk

How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player when fi

By averachardcore - 16-03-2022 08:28

My 1st keeper got overplayed. Yet, I'm still not sure if now he is worse than my sub keeper which is fit. Could you please help and tell me how much does the overplayed form status affect a players productiveness?My 1st keeper got overplayed.
Yet, I'm still not sure if now he is worse than my sub keeper which is fit.
Could you please help and tell me how much does the overplayed form status affect a players productiveness?

 

Page 1

 

Reply

Last Message

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By averachardcore - 16-03-2022 08:32

What would you choose? The: a) overplayed keeper with speed 8 and stamina 9 b) fit keeper with speed 4 and stamina 7 ?What would you choose? The:
a) overplayed keeper with speed 8 and stamina 9
b) fit keeper with speed 4 and stamina 7
?

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By disinocht - 16-03-2022 08:57

[204]
President

Personally, I've [b]never[/b] cared about fitness, but I do believe there is severe impactPersonally, I've never cared about fitness, but I do believe there is severe impact

Ang: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player wh

By jesx - 16-03-2022 09:49

[URBAN]

I initially read the title as "How bad is an [i]overweight[/i] player compared to same player when fit"... Well, I'm gonna go get some coffee to wake up.I initially read the title as "How bad is an overweight player compared to same player when fit"...

Well, I'm gonna go get some coffee to wake up.

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By swaan1 - 16-03-2022 10:35

[STARS]

i would use form packege to restore the 1st goalkeepers form, (Will cost some PT) If that is not possible i would use the one with most form=)i would use form packege to restore the 1st goalkeepers form, (Will cost some PT)

If that is not possible i would use the one with most form=)

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By averachardcore - 16-03-2022 11:10

Thank you!Thank you!

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By evosa - 16-03-2022 12:00

[LEGEND]

I would say there is not enough information right now to make a most adequate decision. What is the experience? other skills? Experience is the second skill I would look if others are same or similar. Why do you have 2 keepers anyway? From financial perspective it seems wise to sell 1 and keep only 1 keeper for senior team. Selling will give you extra money and you'll get rid of his salary. Keepers never get injured or suspended(unless you use them on field position). So sale of 1 keeper seems like best option.I would say there is not enough information right now to make a most adequate decision.

What is the experience? other skills? Experience is the second skill I would look if others are same or similar.

Why do you have 2 keepers anyway? From financial perspective it seems wise to sell 1 and keep only 1 keeper for senior team. Selling will give you extra money and you'll get rid of his salary. Keepers never get injured or suspended(unless you use them on field position). So sale of 1 keeper seems like best option.

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By averachardcore - 16-03-2022 12:25

speed and stamina is the only difference. I did not know that they never get injured or suspended. However, they can get underplayed and overplayed. This is now my case and I'm glad that I have a sub as an option.speed and stamina is the only difference.

I did not know that they never get injured or suspended. However, they can get underplayed and overplayed. This is now my case and I'm glad that I have a sub as an option.

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By averachardcore - 16-03-2022 12:29

With no substitute keeper, the only one will always be overplayed since you'll need him on the field twice every week.With no substitute keeper, the only one will always be overplayed since you'll need him on the field twice every week.

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By viedras20 - 16-03-2022 19:38

[LT-Cm]

A player will get overplayed only if he plays too many friendlies. Put him on the pitch to no more than 4 friendlies and you will never have to think about overplaying.A player will get overplayed only if he plays too many friendlies. Put him on the pitch to no more than 4 friendlies and you will never have to think about overplaying.

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By averachardcore - 16-03-2022 19:42

Thank you! Yeah, I know, but accidents happen. :)Thank you! Yeah, I know, but accidents happen. :)

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By douglaskampl - 17-03-2022 06:50

[BRAU18]
President

Just giving you my two cents. From the Manual: "Form and Experience Although neither can be increased by training, Form and Experience can both help to maximise a player's other attributes." So… rephrasing the question you asked, if you had a player with less stamina, less speed and more experience, which one would you play? In this case I'd go with the 4 speed 7 stamina dude. He is not too far behind.Just giving you my two cents.

From the Manual:

"Form and Experience

Although neither can be increased by training, Form and Experience can both help to maximise a player's other attributes."

So… rephrasing the question you asked, if you had a player with less stamina, less speed and more experience, which one would you play?

In this case I'd go with the 4 speed 7 stamina dude. He is not too far behind.

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By averachardcore - 17-03-2022 06:51

Thank you very much, Doug!Thank you very much, Doug!

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By darkline - 17-03-2022 10:56

[FLUSA]
President

I'd use the form package but if I had to choose, if all other skills are equal, I'd play the fit player.

averachardcore wrote:

What would you choose? The:
a) overplayed keeper with speed 8 and stamina 9
b) fit keeper with speed 4 and stamina 7
?

I'd use the form package but if I had to choose, if all other skills are equal, I'd play the fit player.

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By viedras20 - 17-03-2022 12:53

[LT-Cm]

But if we think about the number of form balls, do you think it would be a big difference if the player is "overplayed", but, for example, has 8 form balls, compared to the desired 9 balls?

darkline wrote:

I'd use the form package but if I had to choose, if all other skills are equal, I'd play the fit player.

But if we think about the number of form balls, do you think it would be a big difference if the player is "overplayed", but, for example, has 8 form balls, compared to the desired 9 balls?

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By averachardcore - 17-03-2022 19:35

exactly my thoughts

viedras20 wrote:

But if we think about the number of form balls, do you think it would be a big difference if the player is "overplayed", but, for example, has 8 form balls, compared to the desired 9 balls?

exactly my thoughts

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By darkline - 18-03-2022 00:34

[FLUSA]
President

I mean... 8 to 9 shouldn't really make a big difference I think.I mean... 8 to 9 shouldn't really make a big difference I think.

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By swaan1 - 20-03-2022 02:14

[STARS]

i think It will make a pretty big diffrence, on the top level you fight for every % advantage you can get. If you get 7-8 form you will have around 20% worse preformance on that player compared to a 9.75 form player. If you are in the lower divisions where it can be huge gaps between teams it is not sure you even notice it, but in the higher divisions you will notice a diffrence.i think It will make a pretty big diffrence, on the top level you fight for every % advantage you can get. If you get 7-8 form you will have around 20% worse preformance on that player compared to a 9.75 form player. If you are in the lower divisions where it can be huge gaps between teams it is not sure you even notice it, but in the higher divisions you will notice a diffrence.

Re: How bad is an overplayed player, compared to same player whe

By k33n3y - 20-03-2022 22:38

Personally I weight every position on total balls. So I've chosen around 6 skills for each position. I combine all balls + exp and + form. The one with the least balls is dropped pretty much.Personally I weight every position on total balls. So I've chosen around 6 skills for each position. I combine all balls + exp and + form. The one with the least balls is dropped pretty much.

 

Page 1