Football » English » Questions & Answers

Report suspicious transfers

By mazides - 12-11-2021 17:14

[PAO]
President

Hi, how can we report suspicious transfers? People create multiple teams in different countries by using VPN and then they pay crazy money to buy players from each other. Is there a way to report those and who is responsible for investigating? It can't go down to one local GM or whatever because they might be involved themselves as well. People will just lose interest and leave the game if we let this happen.Hi, how can we report suspicious transfers? People create multiple teams in different countries by using VPN and then they pay crazy money to buy players from each other. Is there a way to report those and who is responsible for investigating? It can't go down to one local GM or whatever because they might be involved themselves as well. People will just lose interest and leave the game if we let this happen.

 

Page 1

 

Reply

Last Message

Re: Report suspicious transfers

By mazides - 12-11-2021 17:23

[PAO]
President

What I am suggesting is an easy way for everyone to report what they think is a suspicious transfer activity, which is not clear and easy at all right now, so it falls to just a few people to monitor and investigateWhat I am suggesting is an easy way for everyone to report what they think is a suspicious transfer activity, which is not clear and easy at all right now, so it falls to just a few people to monitor and investigate

Re: Report suspicious transfers

By charef (FA) (NC) - 12-11-2021 23:26

[PV]

The only way for now is to report it is by writing in the "support" section.The only way for now is to report it is by writing in the "support" section.

Edited: 12-11-2021 23:26
Total edits: 1

Re: Report suspicious transfers

By mazides - 15-11-2021 01:33

[PAO]
President

Well, my opinion, people should be more involved and have ways to report this as easy as you can do it on social media. That way people will feel that their concerns are heard. Otherwise, one day you think it's not worth playing this game since other players might be cheatingWell, my opinion, people should be more involved and have ways to report this as easy as you can do it on social media. That way people will feel that their concerns are heard. Otherwise, one day you think it's not worth playing this game since other players might be cheating

Re: Report suspicious transfers

By chucky06 - 15-11-2021 04:51

[AUSNZ]
President

You can’t call out people on social media based on “suspicion”. Knowing it’s potentially happening and proving it is another story.

mazides wrote:

Well, my opinion, people should be more involved and have ways to report this as easy as you can do it on social media. That way people will feel that their concerns are heard. Otherwise, one day you think it's not worth playing this game since other players might be cheating

You can’t call out people on social media based on “suspicion”. Knowing it’s potentially happening and proving it is another story.

Re: Report suspicious transfers

By mazides - 15-11-2021 07:38

[PAO]
President

I am not suggesting to call out people. I am suggesting to report suspicious transfers for whoever is responsible to investigate. On social media you can report people and posts. It doesn't go public but it triggers an investigation. What's wrong with it?I am not suggesting to call out people. I am suggesting to report suspicious transfers for whoever is responsible to investigate. On social media you can report people and posts. It doesn't go public but it triggers an investigation. What's wrong with it?

chucky06 wrote:

You can’t call out people on social media based on “suspicion”. Knowing it’s potentially happening and proving it is another story.

Re: Report suspicious transfers

By jere92 - 15-11-2021 08:04

Already you can report suspicious transfers and cheating on support section. Then it will be handled by responsible investigator and they will do thing necessary to punish the reported player/players for their activity.

mazides wrote:

I am not suggesting to call out people. I am suggesting to report suspicious transfers for whoever is responsible to investigate. On social media you can report people and posts. It doesn't go public but it triggers an investigation. What's wrong with it?

Already you can report suspicious transfers and cheating on support section. Then it will be handled by responsible investigator and they will do thing necessary to punish the reported player/players for their activity.

Re: Report suspicious transfers

By mazides - 15-11-2021 17:24

[PAO]
President

And we come back to my first message where I said that this process should be easier and available with a single click next to the transfer.

jere92 wrote:

Already you can report suspicious transfers and cheating on support section. Then it will be handled by responsible investigator and they will do thing necessary to punish the reported player/players for their activity.

And we come back to my first message where I said that this process should be easier and available with a single click next to the transfer.

Re: Report suspicious transfers

By jere92 - 16-11-2021 06:37

Well yeah I wouldn't mind the report option to be in the transfer screen itself but the way you put it was confusing. "It can't go down to one local GM or whatever because they might be involved themselves as well." Saying things like this is kind a big deal if you blame GA and other staff. If you don't trust your local GA or think they cheat I would contact with direct message with other GA:s to discuss what to do. That aside getting direct link to transfer market to report suspicious activity would help both sides players and moderators as players don't Need to start spesify cheaters id and all. As direct link would provide moderators The necessary info by default.Well yeah I wouldn't mind the report option to be in the transfer screen itself but the way you put it was confusing.

"It can't go down to one local GM or whatever because they might be involved themselves as well."

Saying things like this is kind a big deal if you blame GA and other staff. If you don't trust your local GA or think they cheat I would contact with direct message with other GA:s to discuss what to do.

That aside getting direct link to transfer market to report suspicious activity would help both sides players and moderators as players don't Need to start spesify cheaters id and all. As direct link would provide moderators The necessary info by default.

Re: Report suspicious transfers

By mazides - 16-11-2021 17:18

[PAO]
President

Apologies, I didn't mean to offend anyone. I was generally speaking and have no reasons to believe that my local GM is corrupt or anything. I just think that the way it works today it is really down to one person to control the problem, but we cannot pretend the problem does not exist and having every user involved and contributing it would be a step in the right direction.

jere92 wrote:

Well yeah I wouldn't mind the report option to be in the transfer screen itself but the way you put it was confusing.

"It can't go down to one local GM or whatever because they might be involved themselves as well."

Saying things like this is kind a big deal if you blame GA and other staff. If you don't trust your local GA or think they cheat I would contact with direct message with other GA:s to discuss what to do.

That aside getting direct link to transfer market to report suspicious activity would help both sides players and moderators as players don't Need to start spesify cheaters id and all. As direct link would provide moderators The necessary info by default.

Apologies, I didn't mean to offend anyone. I was generally speaking and have no reasons to believe that my local GM is corrupt or anything. I just think that the way it works today it is really down to one person to control the problem, but we cannot pretend the problem does not exist and having every user involved and contributing it would be a step in the right direction.

Re: Report suspicious transfers

By jere92 - 16-11-2021 19:31

https://www.managerzone.com/?p=forum&sub=topic&topic_id=10021836&forum_id=10&sport=soccer in this topic we actually see the list of current investigators not sure if its out dated tho as in top right corner is year 2017. But according to this list there should be over 30 assistants doing investigation on cheating ect. Link to the list under this. https://www.dropbox.com/s/nkb0dkdphiipim5/GA__Chart.pdfhttps://www.managerzone.com/?p=forum&sub=topic&topic_id=10021836&forum_id=10&sport=soccer

in this topic we actually see the list of current investigators not sure if its out dated tho as in top right corner is year 2017. But according to this list there should be over 30 assistants doing investigation on cheating ect. Link to the list under this.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/nkb0dkdphiipim5/GA__Chart.pdf

Re: Report suspicious transfers

By rcostel - 26-12-2021 12:37

[FRF]

I totally agree. A good example would be to have a small tick box next to the transfer of each player, where a person could just tick it if they suspect foul play. Sometimes is a matter of minutes to make a claim, given that once a transfer is finished, the details disappear. Having the option to tick a "suspicious transfer" box and automatically signal it to the team, would make a world of difference.

jere92 wrote:

That aside getting direct link to transfer market to report suspicious activity would help both sides players and moderators as players don't Need to start spesify cheaters id and all. As direct link would provide moderators The necessary info by default.

I totally agree. A good example would be to have a small tick box next to the transfer of each player, where a person could just tick it if they suspect foul play. Sometimes is a matter of minutes to make a claim, given that once a transfer is finished, the details disappear.
Having the option to tick a "suspicious transfer" box and automatically signal it to the team, would make a world of difference.

 

Page 1