Football » English » ManagerZone talk

Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By deleted_8514402 - 20-09-2018 07:45

Hi ppl just got a quick question i have two keepers in my team a gk with 10 balls and 1 with 9 in keeping but the gk with 9 balls has 8 in sta and 8 in speed followed by 4 in PI (training now for 5)and 3 in BC now the one with 10 balls has 4 in sta (training for 5 now) 1 in speed and 2 in PI and 0 in BC which keeper do i use for games how important are the secondary skills and most importantly if it is the 9 ball keeper for now when do i make the switch ?? bit of background i have been using the 10 keeper as i just reached the 9 balls on the other keeper this morning so any help would be great thanks :) p.s 9 ball keeper is maxxed in keeping/sta/speedHi ppl just got a quick question i have two keepers in my team a gk with 10 balls and 1 with 9 in keeping

but the gk with 9 balls has 8 in sta and 8 in speed followed by 4 in PI (training now for 5)and 3 in BC

now the one with 10 balls has 4 in sta (training for 5 now) 1 in speed and 2 in PI and 0 in BC

which keeper do i use for games how important are the secondary skills and most importantly if it is the 9 ball keeper for now when do i make the switch ??

bit of background i have been using the 10 keeper as i just reached the 9 balls on the other keeper this morning so any help would be great thanks :)

p.s 9 ball keeper is maxxed in keeping/sta/speed

 

Page 1

 

Reply

Last Message

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By brock123 - 20-09-2018 08:51

[ENG]

Personally i would play the 10 ball keeper over the 9 ball keeperPersonally i would play the 10 ball keeper over the 9 ball keeper

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By civilu - 20-09-2018 10:55

[RAF]
President

No one can say for sure but personally I would first like to know the experience balls to see whether the 9 baller has any chance - secondary skills balls could justify a switch but experience counts more.No one can say for sure but personally I would first like to know the experience balls to see whether the 9 baller has any chance - secondary skills balls could justify a switch but experience counts more.

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By deleted_8514402 - 20-09-2018 15:40

update 10 ball keeper has 6 exp balls 9 ball keeper has 3update
10 ball keeper has 6 exp balls
9 ball keeper has 3

Ri: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By frony - 20-09-2018 16:56

[FALCO]

10@ gk everytime!10@ gk everytime!

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By aemi - 21-09-2018 02:38

[Canada]

why dont you try the 6 ball keeper? They don't make much difference anyways. They just sit there and the ball goes right into their arms. I watched in on 4D.why dont you try the 6 ball keeper? They don't make much difference anyways. They just sit there and the ball goes right into their arms.

I watched in on 4D.

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By aemi - 21-09-2018 02:38

[Canada]

*it on 4D. Thank you aik for editing your post option, it's a life saver...*it on 4D.

Thank you aik for editing your post option, it's a life saver...

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By jedy22 - 24-09-2018 12:00

[ƘԼƛƝ]

The difference that one keeping ball creates for a keeper is a lot more than the difference that one tackling ball creates for a defender or a difference that one shooting ball creates for a forward. If you are asking for the best option, I would sell both and buy another 10 ball keeper with a higher side skill balls such as ball control, play intelligence, speed and stamina. Till last week my age average first eleven was 24, having a 31 years old keeper with 10 keeping , which is cheaper to find, this week I replaced him with a 22 year old keeper with 10 keeping,7 speed and 9 stamina which is a more expensive but long term plan. If selling and buying is not an option for you , than go with the higher keeping balls. Hope that helps. Feel free to ask on keepers and keeping :)The difference that one keeping ball creates for a keeper is a lot more than the difference that one tackling ball creates for a defender or a difference that one shooting ball creates for a forward.
If you are asking for the best option, I would sell both and buy another 10 ball keeper with a higher side skill balls such as ball control, play intelligence, speed and stamina. Till last week my age average first eleven was 24, having a 31 years old keeper with 10 keeping , which is cheaper to find, this week I replaced him with a 22 year old keeper with 10 keeping,7 speed and 9 stamina which is a more expensive but long term plan. If selling and buying is not an option for you , than go with the higher keeping balls.
Hope that helps.
Feel free to ask on keepers and keeping :)

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By aldebaran - 24-09-2018 12:19

whatever you do, keep in mind that in the last couple of seasons there's the "random keeper behavior" modifier in effect this means that you can see an excellent keeper flop and a mediocre one become the MVP (this doesn't mean that it happens all the time though...so the best bet is to always have a top keeper guarding your posts)whatever you do, keep in mind that in the last couple of seasons there's the "random keeper behavior" modifier in effect

this means that you can see an excellent keeper flop and a mediocre one become the MVP
(this doesn't mean that it happens all the time though...so the best bet is to always have a top keeper guarding your posts)

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By civilu - 26-09-2018 00:24

[RAF]
President

10 gk + 6 exp >>> 9 gk + 3 exp. No matter the rest of the secondaries...10 gk + 6 exp >>> 9 gk + 3 exp. No matter the rest of the secondaries...

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By aikaik (Crew) - 26-09-2018 09:36

[MZS]
President

No problem dude :) So this one is true? :) [img]http://mzimage.com/image.php?lang=en&design=1:000000:000000:::&player=keeper%2520Two:::23::&atts=0:0:0:3u:0:2u:10m:0:1u:0:0:6u:9u&mzv=false[/img] > [img]http://mzimage.com/image.php?lang=en&design=1:000000:000000:::&player=keeper%2520One:::21::&atts=10m:10m:10m:3u:0:2u:9m:10m:1u:10m:0:3u:9u&mzv=false[/img]

aemi wrote:

*it on 4D.

Thank you aik for editing your post option, it's a life saver...

No problem dude :)

civilu wrote:

10 gk + 6 exp >>> 9 gk + 3 exp. No matter the rest of the secondaries...

So this one is true? :)

>

Sv: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By manekaster - 26-09-2018 14:37

[TDF]
President

Thank you for revealing that BC is among the most important skills for goalkeepers, aik [:D]Thank you for revealing that BC is among the most important skills for goalkeepers, aik :D

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By matt_293 - 26-09-2018 19:48

Yes I'd stick the 10 ball keeper in goal and the 9 ball keeper out on the wing!!he's the perfect winger basically hah

aikaik wrote:

No problem dude :)



So this one is true? :)

>

Yes I'd stick the 10 ball keeper in goal and the 9 ball keeper out on the wing!!he's the perfect winger basically hah

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By civilu - 26-09-2018 22:25

[RAF]
President

Aik, as usual you only read the last post. :P I was referring to his 9 and respectively 10 balls keepers... PS: Ball control? Someone lied to you, duuuuudeeeeee!!!Aik, as usual you only read the last post. :P

I was referring to his 9 and respectively 10 balls keepers...

PS: Ball control? Someone lied to you, duuuuudeeeeee!!!

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By aikaik (Crew) - 27-09-2018 00:19

[MZS]
President

Too bad if you're playing short pass due to no heading striker [:D] I always read the last post! [H]

matt_293 wrote:

Yes I'd stick the 10 ball keeper in goal and the 9 ball keeper out on the wing!!he's the perfect winger basically hah

Too bad if you're playing short pass due to no heading striker

civilu wrote:

Aik, as usual you only read the last post. :P

I was referring to his 9 and respectively 10 balls keepers...

PS: Ball control? Someone lied to you, duuuuudeeeeee!!!

I always read the last post!

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By aikaik (Crew) - 27-09-2018 00:20

[MZS]
President

I Usually train it after the other 10's, but no idea if it actually does help much [:P]

manekaster wrote:

Thank you for revealing that BC is among the most important skills for goalkeepers, aik

I Usually train it after the other 10's, but no idea if it actually does help much

Sv: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By manekaster - 27-09-2018 01:27

[TDF]
President

Says the Crew member who won Allsvenskan and the Swedish cup just a couple seasons ago [:P] You know us Norwegians make jokes about you Swedes, but you're know better [:D] Jokes aside, have you ever seen a goalie dribble or use his feet moving the ball forward? My theory is that BC is slightly more useful than heading and shooting for a GK. I also think that handling the ball with his hands is covered by the keeper skill, while his cross balls technique is coverer by... cross balls. Thus i'll rather train him in set pieces after the 5 obvious skills. At least he will do some goal kicks, which in fact are set pieces, every game. And you'll also leave another open spot on your BC station on your training field.

aikaik wrote:

But no idea if it actually does help much :P

Says the Crew member who won Allsvenskan and the Swedish cup just a couple seasons ago :P You know us Norwegians make jokes about you Swedes, but you're know better :D

Jokes aside, have you ever seen a goalie dribble or use his feet moving the ball forward? My theory is that BC is slightly more useful than heading and shooting for a GK. I also think that handling the ball with his hands is covered by the keeper skill, while his cross balls technique is coverer by... cross balls. Thus i'll rather train him in set pieces after the 5 obvious skills. At least he will do some goal kicks, which in fact are set pieces, every game. And you'll also leave another open spot on your BC station on your training field.

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By aikaik (Crew) - 27-09-2018 09:50

[MZS]
President

Haha that is funny actually... my goalie back then: [img]http://www.mzimage.com/image.php?lang=en&design=1:000000:000000:::&player=Ainar%20Aiello:::28::&atts=8m:7m:9m:3u:0:2u:10m:10m:1u:8m:0:9u:9u&mzv=false[/img] He arrived with 10 BC, nothing I trained and not sure if it helped him to handle the ball any better [:D] Got him in after a couple of seasons to strengthen the goalie position instead of playing the club icon Ivan Turina [H] [img]http://www.mzimage.com/image.php?lang=en&design=1:000000:000000:::&player=Ivan%20Turina:::30::&atts=6:5:7m:7m:1u:2u:10m:8m:1u:5m:6m:10m:9u&mzv=false[/img]

manekaster wrote:

Says the Crew member who won Allsvenskan and the Swedish cup just a couple seasons ago You know us Norwegians make jokes about you Swedes, but you're know better

Jokes aside, have you ever seen a goalie dribble or use his feet moving the ball forward? My theory is that BC is slightly more useful than heading and shooting for a GK. I also think that handling the ball with his hands is covered by the keeper skill, while his cross balls technique is coverer by... cross balls. Thus i'll rather train him in set pieces after the 5 obvious skills. At least he will do some goal kicks, which in fact are set pieces, every game. And you'll also leave another open spot on your BC station on your training field.

Haha that is funny actually... my goalie back then:


He arrived with 10 BC, nothing I trained and not sure if it helped him to handle the ball any better Got him in after a couple of seasons to strengthen the goalie position instead of playing the club icon Ivan Turina

Sv: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By leatherman - 01-10-2018 16:24

[TDF]

Nothing is better then 10,but i believe that a goalie with 9 balls in keeper and a lot of balls in other relevant skills is better better with 10 in goalkeepeing and almost nothing elseNothing is better then 10,but i believe that a goalie with 9 balls in keeper and a lot of balls in other relevant skills is better better with 10 in goalkeepeing and almost nothing else

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By munts93 - 24-10-2018 02:15

[AUSNZ]

I've got a 9 Ball Keeper with 4 speed/stam and a 10 ball keeper with no secondaries. Have taken the plunge while in Div 2 to put the 10 ball in TC and make do with the backup! Hope it doesn't let in too many more goalsI've got a 9 Ball Keeper with 4 speed/stam and a 10 ball keeper with no secondaries. Have taken the plunge while in Div 2 to put the 10 ball in TC and make do with the backup! Hope it doesn't let in too many more goals

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By aemi - 24-10-2018 02:59

[Canada]

I stick with the 6 balls keeping dude. He is awesome, great personality, he donates monthly to charity.I stick with the 6 balls keeping dude. He is awesome, great personality, he donates monthly to charity.

Re: Keeper question GK9 vs GK10 when to switch

By obelisk - 25-10-2018 01:50

[PL♕]

I would do that too

matt_293 wrote:

Yes I'd stick the 10 ball keeper in goal and the 9 ball keeper out on the wing!!he's the perfect winger basically hah

I would do that too

 

Page 1