Football » English » ManagerZone talk

Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By powdersnow (Crew) - 02-04-2025 14:26

[CR3W]

[color=green]This is a thread for comments on this news article: https://www.managerzone.com/?p=news&nid=118713[/color] [b]In early May we will roll out an update which will allow you to to see skill maxings and player talents on the results page in the transfer market, without having to visit the player's Training Graphs. As part of the update, we will also make in [u]important change[/u]: it will no longer be possible to sell players with hidden Training Graphs. All transfer listed players will be shown with talents, maxings and Training Graphs visible.[/b] This update is being made with two key goals in mind: Simplicity and Usability: We're always working to make ManagerZone more user-friendly. By showing key information upfront, skilled managers can now quickly assess a player's potential and value, making the transfer process faster and more intuitive. Fair Play and Transparency: We think transparency is essential for a fair and balanced marketplace. This change ensures players are traded at prices that better reflect their true value. Whether it's overpricing players with hidden weaknesses or transferring underpriced talent "under the radar", lack of transparency often leads to frustration and imbalance. This update aims to help prevent that. If you have thoughts about this coming update, you are very welcome to share them here!This is a thread for comments on this news article: https://www.managerzone.com/?p=news&nid=118713

In early May we will roll out an update which will allow you to to see skill maxings and player talents on the results page in the transfer market, without having to visit the player's Training Graphs. As part of the update, we will also make in important change: it will no longer be possible to sell players with hidden Training Graphs. All transfer listed players will be shown with talents, maxings and Training Graphs visible.

This update is being made with two key goals in mind:

Simplicity and Usability: We're always working to make ManagerZone more user-friendly. By showing key information upfront, skilled managers can now quickly assess a player's potential and value, making the transfer process faster and more intuitive.

Fair Play and Transparency: We think transparency is essential for a fair and balanced marketplace. This change ensures players are traded at prices that better reflect their true value. Whether it's overpricing players with hidden weaknesses or transferring underpriced talent "under the radar", lack of transparency often leads to frustration and imbalance. This update aims to help prevent that.

If you have thoughts about this coming update, you are very welcome to share them here!

Previous

Page 1 2 3

Next

 

Last Message

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By ruben228 - 05-04-2025 20:47

[FedeGu]

Considero que también debería controlarse el precio de los jugadores,creo que lo correcto seria que el valor de transferencia se un jugador no supere un porcentaje de su valor real por ejemplo un 50% así si vale un millón no exceda del 1500000 ya que se seguir cómo está actualmente únicamente los equipos grandes tienen acceso a jugadores de alto valor o bien aquellos que han estado varios años sin realizar inversión acumulando su capitalConsidero que también debería controlarse el precio de los jugadores,creo que lo correcto seria que el valor de transferencia se un jugador no supere un porcentaje de su valor real por ejemplo un 50% así si vale un millón no exceda del 1500000 ya que se seguir cómo está actualmente únicamente los equipos grandes tienen acceso a jugadores de alto valor o bien aquellos que han estado varios años sin realizar inversión acumulando su capital

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By kadette - 06-04-2025 13:09

O que seria mais interessante é um controle das vendas dos jogadores, não creio que uma equipe consiga fazer tanto dinheiro para ficar conseguindo comprar jogadores por preços exurbitantes commo vejo acontecer, para mim existem equipes fakes montadas para comprar jogadores mediucres por altas quantias para mais tarde quem vendeu possa ter capital suficiente para manter uma equipe de alto nível no jogo, é isso seria de fácil vizualização, pois a comparação dos gastos do elenco não podem ultrapassar a receita gerida pela equipe, e a equipe que consegue ficar se mantendo por vendas de jogadores mediocres deve existir ai um grande cambalacho.O que seria mais interessante é um controle das vendas dos jogadores, não creio que uma equipe consiga fazer tanto dinheiro para ficar conseguindo comprar jogadores por preços exurbitantes commo vejo acontecer, para mim existem equipes fakes montadas para comprar jogadores mediucres por altas quantias para mais tarde quem vendeu possa ter capital suficiente para manter uma equipe de alto nível no jogo, é isso seria de fácil vizualização, pois a comparação dos gastos do elenco não podem ultrapassar a receita gerida pela equipe, e a equipe que consegue ficar se mantendo por vendas de jogadores mediocres deve existir ai um grande cambalacho.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By kadette - 06-04-2025 13:14

Translating: What would be more interesting is a control of player sales. I don't believe that a team can make so much money to be able to buy players at exorbitant prices as I see happening. For me, there are fake teams set up to buy mediocre players for high amounts so that later, whoever sold them can have enough capital to maintain a high-level team in the game. This would be easy to visualize, because the comparison of the squad's expenses cannot exceed the revenue generated by the team, and the team that manages to maintain itself by selling mediocre players must be involved in a big scam.

kadette wrote:

O que seria mais interessante é um controle das vendas dos jogadores, não creio que uma equipe consiga fazer tanto dinheiro para ficar conseguindo comprar jogadores por preços exurbitantes commo vejo acontecer, para mim existem equipes fakes montadas para comprar jogadores mediucres por altas quantias para mais tarde quem vendeu possa ter capital suficiente para manter uma equipe de alto nível no jogo, é isso seria de fácil vizualização, pois a comparação dos gastos do elenco não podem ultrapassar a receita gerida pela equipe, e a equipe que consegue ficar se mantendo por vendas de jogadores mediocres deve existir ai um grande cambalacho.

Translating:

What would be more interesting is a control of player sales. I don't believe that a team can make so much money to be able to buy players at exorbitant prices as I see happening. For me, there are fake teams set up to buy mediocre players for high amounts so that later, whoever sold them can have enough capital to maintain a high-level team in the game. This would be easy to visualize, because the comparison of the squad's expenses cannot exceed the revenue generated by the team, and the team that manages to maintain itself by selling mediocre players must be involved in a big scam.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By neehouck - 06-04-2025 16:24

Eu gostei do trabalho da Crew para acabar com as trapaças. Já é visível no mercado de transferência que a venda de jogadores está mais equilibrada e a longo prazo deve gerar bons resultados pra quem joga limpo. Acredito que a mudança no mercado de transferência vai deixar as trapaças mais difíceis ainda, deixando o jogo mais equilibrado ainda. Se você conhece um jogador antigo de MZ que parou de jogar por causa das trapaças, avise a ele que está chegando a hora de dar uma nova chance pro MZ. Translating: I liked the work the Crew did to end cheating. It is already clear in the transfer market that player sales are more balanced and in the long term it should generate good results for those who play fair. I believe that the change in the transfer market will make cheating even more difficult, making the game even more balanced. If you know a older MZ player who stopped playing because of cheating, let him know that it is time to give MZ another chance.Eu gostei do trabalho da Crew para acabar com as trapaças. Já é visível no mercado de transferência que a venda de jogadores está mais equilibrada e a longo prazo deve gerar bons resultados pra quem joga limpo. Acredito que a mudança no mercado de transferência vai deixar as trapaças mais difíceis ainda, deixando o jogo mais equilibrado ainda. Se você conhece um jogador antigo de MZ que parou de jogar por causa das trapaças, avise a ele que está chegando a hora de dar uma nova chance pro MZ.

Translating:

I liked the work the Crew did to end cheating. It is already clear in the transfer market that player sales are more balanced and in the long term it should generate good results for those who play fair. I believe that the change in the transfer market will make cheating even more difficult, making the game even more balanced. If you know a older MZ player who stopped playing because of cheating, let him know that it is time to give MZ another chance.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By hooper14 - 07-04-2025 10:41

[ENG]
President

Are you putting tariffs on any American team buying players from foreign teams? 🤣Are you putting tariffs on any American team buying players from foreign teams? 🤣

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By powdersnow (Crew) - 09-04-2025 10:22

[CR3W]

Not sure about that one, it isn't on our radar at the moment but I'll make a note about it. Thanks for the suggestion.

frankiejhoffa wrote:

Is there going to be a tweak on the approximate salary that is shown when buying a player ? In my experience it is not accurate .
Cheers Hoffa

Not sure about that one, it isn't on our radar at the moment but I'll make a note about it. Thanks for the suggestion.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By powdersnow (Crew) - 09-04-2025 10:40

[CR3W]

I just want to acknowledge that fact that this is a good argument, and it is something we've discussed quite a bit internally. Some managers who don't mind spending lots of time digging through data in search of undervalued gems, might find that practice a little less rewarding now. But we do have to consider the amount of grinding (as in performing repetitive tasks) that this causes, and try to figure out a decent balance. You still can get an edge over other managers just by checking the transfer market often, and by being skilled enough to recognise undervalued talent. Persistent and thorough managers can still get rewarded, but hopefully in a more entertaining and less laborious way than before.

webregas wrote:

Good update on removing hidden training graphs.

Not sure on making maxings and stars counts visible without having to click into the reports. Whilst it simplifies the process, I feel like a big part of what makes the transfer market great is having to spend time to uncover talent/ key unmaxed skills.

I just want to acknowledge that fact that this is a good argument, and it is something we've discussed quite a bit internally. Some managers who don't mind spending lots of time digging through data in search of undervalued gems, might find that practice a little less rewarding now.

But we do have to consider the amount of grinding (as in performing repetitive tasks) that this causes, and try to figure out a decent balance. You still can get an edge over other managers just by checking the transfer market often, and by being skilled enough to recognise undervalued talent. Persistent and thorough managers can still get rewarded, but hopefully in a more entertaining and less laborious way than before.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By powdersnow (Crew) - 09-04-2025 10:51

[CR3W]

This would turn into a "first come, first serve" kind of market which would not favor those who try to build a long-term strategy, by building their economy, making smart investments, etc. That goes against the very core mechanics of ManagerZone. Honestly I could post a very long reply to your comments because this is a huge discussion, but I will just leave it there. 😊

ruben228 wrote:

Considero que también debería controlarse el precio de los jugadores,creo que lo correcto seria que el valor de transferencia se un jugador no supere un porcentaje de su valor real por ejemplo un 50% así si vale un millón no exceda del 1500000 ya que se seguir cómo está actualmente únicamente los equipos grandes tienen acceso a jugadores de alto valor o bien aquellos que han estado varios años sin realizar inversión acumulando su capital

This would turn into a "first come, first serve" kind of market which would not favor those who try to build a long-term strategy, by building their economy, making smart investments, etc. That goes against the very core mechanics of ManagerZone. Honestly I could post a very long reply to your comments because this is a huge discussion, but I will just leave it there. 😊

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By frankiejhoffa - 13-04-2025 23:31

[AUSNZ]

Cheers Powder - I just purchased a player and the approximate salary shown on my winning bid was $12k per week. When he arrived today his salary was 18k. This is a 50% increase . As i stated before the numbers are not even close. Hoffa

powdersnow wrote:

Not sure about that one, it isn't on our radar at the moment but I'll make a note about it. Thanks for the suggestion.

Cheers Powder -

I just purchased a player and the approximate salary shown on my winning bid was $12k per week. When he arrived today his salary was 18k. This is a 50% increase . As i stated before the numbers are not even close.

Hoffa

Ang: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By the__champ (FA) - 15-04-2025 14:10

[MZ DK]

Could you introduce a max bid option, like we see in online auction. Like two ways of bid. Normal as now where you bid a certain amount and it change to that. A max bid option where you put in your max bid. And Then you automatic out bid if another bid until you reach your max Price. Like player listed to 1 mill But you see you cant be there at deadline. You value him to 3 mill. Then you put in your max bid to 3 mill. Then the system bids 1 mill for you and you are the current winner. Then one manager comes and over bid you to 1.1 mill. Then the system automatic place a new bid for you and you are now winning at 1.2 mill and so on Will it goes until your max bid is reached and Then it wont bid more for you. This is a Way you Can compete when deadlines is out of reach for you. It would be a good addonCould you introduce a max bid option, like we see in online auction.
Like two ways of bid.
Normal as now where you bid a certain amount and it change to that.

A max bid option where you put in your max bid. And Then you automatic out bid if another bid until you reach your max Price.

Like player listed to 1 mill But you see you cant be there at deadline. You value him to 3 mill.
Then you put in your max bid to 3 mill. Then the system bids 1 mill for you and you are the current winner.
Then one manager comes and over bid you to 1.1 mill. Then the system automatic place a new bid for you and you are now winning at 1.2 mill and so on Will it goes until your max bid is reached and Then it wont bid more for you.
This is a Way you Can compete when deadlines is out of reach for you.

It would be a good addon

Edited: 15-04-2025 14:11
Total edits: 1

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By capibaribe (RA) - 18-04-2025 16:10

[FIQ]

Considering that one of the goals of this change is to make life harder for cheaters—especially with the planned updates to the market interface—I’d like to reiterate a suggestion I previously shared on the administrative forum. It would be extremely helpful to include a simple button that allows users to flag suspicious sales. This button could appear both on market listings and on the bids page, as well as on team pages, making it easier to report farms as well. Clicking the button would open a modal where the user could add comments and explain the reason for the report. This approach would be much more effective and user-friendly than the current ticket system. From a technical standpoint, the implementation could be quite simple: it would only require the creation of a single table in the database to store these reports—or alternatively, just two additional columns (in JSON format) in the existing market table.Considering that one of the goals of this change is to make life harder for cheaters—especially with the planned updates to the market interface—I’d like to reiterate a suggestion I previously shared on the administrative forum.

It would be extremely helpful to include a simple button that allows users to flag suspicious sales. This button could appear both on market listings and on the bids page, as well as on team pages, making it easier to report farms as well.

Clicking the button would open a modal where the user could add comments and explain the reason for the report. This approach would be much more effective and user-friendly than the current ticket system.

From a technical standpoint, the implementation could be quite simple: it would only require the creation of a single table in the database to store these reports—or alternatively, just two additional columns (in JSON format) in the existing market table.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By lebanon21 (NC) - 24-04-2025 18:21

I like that option. It would make the cheats reporting process much faster and probably easier to put several cheaters on Crew's radar. There should be some minimum requirement mechanism though so we don't have too many reports being spammed. How are the known cheaters abusing the bids on the total trash players? Maybe there needs to be a bid higher than a certain % of players value to enable the report button?

capibaribe wrote:

Considering that one of the goals of this change is to make life harder for cheaters—especially with the planned updates to the market interface—I’d like to reiterate a suggestion I previously shared on the administrative forum.

It would be extremely helpful to include a simple button that allows users to flag suspicious sales. This button could appear both on market listings and on the bids page, as well as on team pages, making it easier to report farms as well.

Clicking the button would open a modal where the user could add comments and explain the reason for the report. This approach would be much more effective and user-friendly than the current ticket system.

From a technical standpoint, the implementation could be quite simple: it would only require the creation of a single table in the database to store these reports—or alternatively, just two additional columns (in JSON format) in the existing market table.

I like that option. It would make the cheats reporting process much faster and probably easier to put several cheaters on Crew's radar.

There should be some minimum requirement mechanism though so we don't have too many reports being spammed. How are the known cheaters abusing the bids on the total trash players? Maybe there needs to be a bid higher than a certain % of players value to enable the report button?

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By guillermofrank - 24-04-2025 20:17

[COTTON]
President

Esto sería llevar al extremo la ventaja de los equipos poderosos en el mercado. No sólo contarían con el capital, sino con las herramientas técnicas para poder llevarse a un jugador aún sin poder estar presente en la subasta No, de ninguna manera podría estar de acuerdo con esta modificación (aunque he leído que hay usuarios de un país que tienen una herramienta para poder hacerlo)

the__champ wrote:

Could you introduce a max bid option, like we see in online auction.
Like two ways of bid.
Normal as now where you bid a certain amount and it change to that.

A max bid option where you put in your max bid. And Then you automatic out bid if another bid until you reach your max Price.

Like player listed to 1 mill But you see you cant be there at deadline. You value him to 3 mill.
Then you put in your max bid to 3 mill. Then the system bids 1 mill for you and you are the current winner.
Then one manager comes and over bid you to 1.1 mill. Then the system automatic place a new bid for you and you are now winning at 1.2 mill and so on Will it goes until your max bid is reached and Then it wont bid more for you.
This is a Way you Can compete when deadlines is out of reach for you.

It would be a good addon

Esto sería llevar al extremo la ventaja de los equipos poderosos en el mercado. No sólo contarían con el capital, sino con las herramientas técnicas para poder llevarse a un jugador aún sin poder estar presente en la subasta

No, de ninguna manera podría estar de acuerdo con esta modificación (aunque he leído que hay usuarios de un país que tienen una herramienta para poder hacerlo)

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By guillermofrank - 24-04-2025 20:24

[COTTON]
President

Si el debate va por simplificar o no el trabajo de los managers, y si esto es facilitar o no el trabajo de ellos, creo que la creación del "Scout" ha modificado por completo estas pautas, dado que ahora "en un click" uno sabe si el jugador puede tener futuro o no, mientras con el sistema anterior llevaba varias temporadas saberlo. Eso sí ha sido una herramienta que modificó y simplificó por completo el trabajo de los managers! Si tras incorporar semejante modificación en el juego, el debate pasa a ser si visualizar el scout en los filtros del mercado es facilitar "demasiado" el trabajo de los managers, bueno... creo realmente que es un planteo sin demasiado sentido. Siempre se pudo filtrar por jugadores de selección nacional, por cantidad de atributos, incluso por valores nominales o de últimas ofertas... tras la creación del Scout realmente no encuentro sentido a debatir si "facilita" demasiado el trabajo de los managers incorporando el scout a los filtros de mercado. Insisto, es sólo mi opinión, aunque creo compartida por muchos. Espero se incorpore esta modificación que tanto esperamos. Saludos

powdersnow wrote:

I just want to acknowledge that fact that this is a good argument, and it is something we've discussed quite a bit internally. Some managers who don't mind spending lots of time digging through data in search of undervalued gems, might find that practice a little less rewarding now.

But we do have to consider the amount of grinding (as in performing repetitive tasks) that this causes, and try to figure out a decent balance. You still can get an edge over other managers just by checking the transfer market often, and by being skilled enough to recognise undervalued talent. Persistent and thorough managers can still get rewarded, but hopefully in a more entertaining and less laborious way than before.

Si el debate va por simplificar o no el trabajo de los managers, y si esto es facilitar o no el trabajo de ellos, creo que la creación del "Scout" ha modificado por completo estas pautas, dado que ahora "en un click" uno sabe si el jugador puede tener futuro o no, mientras con el sistema anterior llevaba varias temporadas saberlo.
Eso sí ha sido una herramienta que modificó y simplificó por completo el trabajo de los managers!
Si tras incorporar semejante modificación en el juego, el debate pasa a ser si visualizar el scout en los filtros del mercado es facilitar "demasiado" el trabajo de los managers, bueno... creo realmente que es un planteo sin demasiado sentido.
Siempre se pudo filtrar por jugadores de selección nacional, por cantidad de atributos, incluso por valores nominales o de últimas ofertas... tras la creación del Scout realmente no encuentro sentido a debatir si "facilita" demasiado el trabajo de los managers incorporando el scout a los filtros de mercado.

Insisto, es sólo mi opinión, aunque creo compartida por muchos. Espero se incorpore esta modificación que tanto esperamos. Saludos

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By lebanon21 (NC) - 25-04-2025 22:51

Hard No from me.

the__champ wrote:

Could you introduce a max bid option, like we see in online auction.
Like two ways of bid.
Normal as now where you bid a certain amount and it change to that.

A max bid option where you put in your max bid. And Then you automatic out bid if another bid until you reach your max Price.

Like player listed to 1 mill But you see you cant be there at deadline. You value him to 3 mill.
Then you put in your max bid to 3 mill. Then the system bids 1 mill for you and you are the current winner.
Then one manager comes and over bid you to 1.1 mill. Then the system automatic place a new bid for you and you are now winning at 1.2 mill and so on Will it goes until your max bid is reached and Then it wont bid more for you.
This is a Way you Can compete when deadlines is out of reach for you.

It would be a good addon

Hard No from me.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By subirasport (NCA) - 26-04-2025 18:49

In Andorra, we can't even buy our own domestic players because [b]you[/b] set the same purchase limit regardless if the team is in a big country like Argentina or in Andorra while these markets are completely different. In my country we constantly buy/sell players to each other even from teams on the same league and this is not cheating, it's just that there are very few teams to get domestic players from (in Hockey we are just 3 teams, where are we supposed to get our players from??), yet we keep getting market warnings and purchases blocks that prevent us from fighting for our few good domestic players whom always end up in foreign teams not because of a higher bid but due to we can't place an offer. If we have a different foreign players quota between big and small countries, there should be a difference in the amount of domestic players we can buy from the same [u]domestic[/u] teams.

powdersnow wrote:

Yes, clubs in smaller leagues can reach the top in their country more easily, and this has certain important benefits. But on the other hand, their player market is much more limited (due to foreign player quotas, as you mentioned) which means they become more reliant on home grown talent. An elite manager in Andorra may npt be able to have both a Senior and a U21 team, both packed full of top talent, like a manager in Argentina have. The Andorran manager also has to think harder about how to compensate for players that are missing due to training camps and the like, because their own homegrown players has to step in when key players are away.

In Andorra, we can't even buy our own domestic players because you set the same purchase limit regardless if the team is in a big country like Argentina or in Andorra while these markets are completely different.
In my country we constantly buy/sell players to each other even from teams on the same league and this is not cheating, it's just that there are very few teams to get domestic players from (in Hockey we are just 3 teams, where are we supposed to get our players from??), yet we keep getting market warnings and purchases blocks that prevent us from fighting for our few good domestic players whom always end up in foreign teams not because of a higher bid but due to we can't place an offer.
If we have a different foreign players quota between big and small countries, there should be a difference in the amount of domestic players we can buy from the same domestic teams.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By cometodubaihabibi (NC) - 26-04-2025 19:17

[ANDLTR]

100% correct! its crazy to have the same limit to buy a player between clubs from poland and sweden and same for very small nations with 5-10 active teams! because when you have only 10 teams in your country its possible to have more than 2 players from the same team! this must change

subirasport wrote:

In Andorra, we can't even buy our own domestic players because you set the same purchase limit regardless if the team is in a big country like Argentina or in Andorra while these markets are completely different.
In my country we constantly buy/sell players to each other even from teams on the same league and this is not cheating, it's just that there are very few teams to get domestic players from (in Hockey we are just 3 teams, where are we supposed to get our players from??), yet we keep getting market warnings and purchases blocks that prevent us from fighting for our few good domestic players whom always end up in foreign teams not because of a higher bid but due to we can't place an offer.
If we have a different foreign players quota between big and small countries, there should be a difference in the amount of domestic players we can buy from the same domestic teams.

100% correct! its crazy to have the same limit to buy a player between clubs from poland and sweden and same for very small nations with 5-10 active teams! because when you have only 10 teams in your country its possible to have more than 2 players from the same team! this must change

Beantwortet: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By kabini - 27-04-2025 04:35

[RWRK]

[color=blue]If others state their reasonable wishes here, I´d like to post a wish - or better a question here too: [b]Why this top-price-limit when selling a player?[/b] I have a real good player but cannot sell him with a realistic start price: [img]https://i.imgur.com/v7STi7S.jpeg[/img] 4.5 millions (euro) ? Is there any (good) reason for this limation? Cause if I´m lucky - the right time, people have the money ready etc. I´ll get my 15/20 millions, if not, I earn 4,5 millions °?° This goes together with the unrealistic werth of the MZ-players, it stopps wit 1.3-1.5 millions, no matter which player ... => this is far from reality. [i]I´d be happy, if players would show a realistic werth, hands realistic starting prices would be possible automatically ...[/i] [b]So is there a good reason, don´t know: fairness, programming or whatever? - why that isn´t done already since a long time?[/b] thx in before![/color]If others state their reasonable wishes here, I´d like to post a wish - or better a question here too:

Why this top-price-limit when selling a player?

I have a real good player but cannot sell him with a realistic start price:



4.5 millions (euro) ?
Is there any (good) reason for this limation?
Cause if I´m lucky - the right time, people have the money ready etc. I´ll get my 15/20 millions, if not, I earn 4,5 millions °?°

This goes together with the unrealistic werth of the MZ-players, it stopps wit 1.3-1.5 millions, no matter which player ... => this is far from reality.

I´d be happy, if players would show a realistic werth, hands realistic starting prices would be possible automatically ...

So is there a good reason, don´t know: fairness, programming or whatever?
- why that isn´t done already since a long time?
thx in before!

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By vandorst - 27-04-2025 20:08

[LEGS]

Boa tarde, boa mudança. Porém há muito mais a ser feito, é necessário haver um limitador de preço de venda, por exemplo: não pode o valor de venda ser superior.a 100% do valor já contido no atleta...hoje está um ZONA, bagre sendo vendido por 14 milhões....inflação requer intervenção para ser contida.Boa tarde, boa mudança. Porém há muito mais a ser feito, é necessário haver um limitador de preço de venda, por exemplo: não pode o valor de venda ser superior.a 100% do valor já contido no atleta...hoje está um ZONA, bagre sendo vendido por 14 milhões....inflação requer intervenção para ser contida.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By powdersnow (Crew) - 28-04-2025 10:41

[CR3W]

Interesting idea, thanks for the suggestion.

the__champ wrote:

Could you introduce a max bid option, like we see in online auction.
Like two ways of bid.
Normal as now where you bid a certain amount and it change to that.

A max bid option where you put in your max bid. And Then you automatic out bid if another bid until you reach your max Price.

Like player listed to 1 mill But you see you cant be there at deadline. You value him to 3 mill.
Then you put in your max bid to 3 mill. Then the system bids 1 mill for you and you are the current winner.
Then one manager comes and over bid you to 1.1 mill. Then the system automatic place a new bid for you and you are now winning at 1.2 mill and so on Will it goes until your max bid is reached and Then it wont bid more for you.
This is a Way you Can compete when deadlines is out of reach for you.

It would be a good addon

Interesting idea, thanks for the suggestion.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By powdersnow (Crew) - 28-04-2025 10:57

[CR3W]

At the moment you need to go through the support form and choose "Report Cheater". We might consider something like you suggested in the future, but I cant make any promises.

capibaribe wrote:

Considering that one of the goals of this change is to make life harder for cheaters—especially with the planned updates to the market interface—I’d like to reiterate a suggestion I previously shared on the administrative forum.

It would be extremely helpful to include a simple button that allows users to flag suspicious sales. This button could appear both on market listings and on the bids page, as well as on team pages, making it easier to report farms as well.

Clicking the button would open a modal where the user could add comments and explain the reason for the report. This approach would be much more effective and user-friendly than the current ticket system.

From a technical standpoint, the implementation could be quite simple: it would only require the creation of a single table in the database to store these reports—or alternatively, just two additional columns (in JSON format) in the existing market table.

At the moment you need to go through the support form and choose "Report Cheater". We might consider something like you suggested in the future, but I cant make any promises.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By bignorbi - 06-05-2025 10:17

[FRADI]
President

Hi! When will it arrive?Hi! When will it arrive?

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By powdersnow (Crew) - 06-05-2025 11:05

[CR3W]

We will add it next week, which exact day is not yet decided.

bignorbi wrote:

Hi! When will it arrive?

We will add it next week, which exact day is not yet decided.

Sv: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By jeppepsi - 06-05-2025 11:07

[AIKFED]

When will this be implemented?When will this be implemented?

Sv: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By jeppepsi - 06-05-2025 11:08

[AIKFED]

Sorry, missed answer above... Is there a screenshot of how this will look?Sorry, missed answer above... Is there a screenshot of how this will look?

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By bignorbi - 06-05-2025 23:51

[FRADI]
President

Thx! :-)

powdersnow wrote:

We will add it next week, which exact day is not yet decided.

Thx! :-)

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By doug7887 - 10-05-2025 18:14

[LEGEND]

Nice changesNice changes

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By powdersnow (Crew) - 12-05-2025 10:02

[CR3W]

Just to let you know, we are planning to launch this on [b]Wednesday[/b].Just to let you know, we are planning to launch this on Wednesday.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By lebanon21 (NC) - 14-05-2025 12:13

I appreciate the update, it's a great addition, but...ffs, what is this UI? Looks absolute dogshit. Those "1" & "2" next to the skills make it all look mixed up. Make the skill name in green font if it's the high potential and red if it's low potentialI appreciate the update, it's a great addition, but...ffs, what is this UI? Looks absolute dogshit.
Those "1" & "2" next to the skills make it all look mixed up.
Make the skill name in green font if it's the high potential and red if it's low potential

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By jho - 14-05-2025 12:34

Yes, I agree. Is it possible to make the scoutinging report visible? I want to read about the high and low potential. Not seeing 1s or 2s.Yes, I agree. Is it possible to make the scoutinging report visible? I want to read about the high and low potential. Not seeing 1s or 2s.

Sv: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By tiger13 - 14-05-2025 12:56

[LEGEND]

Nice update 😀Nice update 😀

Ant: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By thendric - 14-05-2025 12:59

[CTLL]

and have at least we should have filters in order to search for specific potentials. This is actually a regression compared to what we had with the tampermonkey extention. CTRL + F with HP4 doesn't work anymoreand have at least we should have filters in order to search for specific potentials. This is actually a regression compared to what we had with the tampermonkey extention. CTRL + F with HP4 doesn't work anymore

Ant: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By daniel2004 - 14-05-2025 13:59

[BNL]

Fantastic update! However, I think points 1 and 2 are a bit unclear. They can be confusing at first glance. Perhaps it would be helpful to categorize players based on 4 HP or 3 HP in the categorizations as well.Fantastic update! However, I think points 1 and 2 are a bit unclear. They can be confusing at first glance. Perhaps it would be helpful to categorize players based on 4 HP or 3 HP in the categorizations as well.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By webregas - 14-05-2025 14:04

[MZ UKI]
President

Not being able to see the HP and LP is a bit of a step back for me. Wasn’t aware that was under considerationNot being able to see the HP and LP is a bit of a step back for me. Wasn’t aware that was under consideration

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By tarcinmomczak - 14-05-2025 14:09

This is extremely not user friendly and not clear. As pointed by [i]@thendric[/i], huge regression compared to what we had with the tampermonkey extention.This is extremely not user friendly and not clear.
As pointed by @thendric, huge regression compared to what we had with the tampermonkey extention.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By webregas - 14-05-2025 14:29

[MZ UKI]
President

My bad - can see by the numbers by the skills. Would suggest this could be clearerMy bad - can see by the numbers by the skills. Would suggest this could be clearer

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By bessarion - 14-05-2025 14:38

[BGB]

I cannot bid on player's on the transfer market page, only when shortlisted. Bidding icon is disabled/grayed out. When shortlisted, icon is enabled.I cannot bid on player's on the transfer market page, only when shortlisted. Bidding icon is disabled/grayed out. When shortlisted, icon is enabled.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By donalton - 14-05-2025 15:06

[VF 🌋]
President

The update looks great! But it would be even better if the classifications kept the traditional colors (H4 in pink, H3 in blue, H/L2 in yellow, and L1 in red) instead of just using numbers (1 for H and 2 for L). Many users are already used to this color scheme through extensions and spreadsheets, which would make it more intuitive to read.The update looks great! But it would be even better if the classifications kept the traditional colors (H4 in pink, H3 in blue, H/L2 in yellow, and L1 in red) instead of just using numbers (1 for H and 2 for L). Many users are already used to this color scheme through extensions and spreadsheets, which would make it more intuitive to read.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By roseto - 14-05-2025 15:10

Bravo on showing ALL training graphs.Bravo on showing ALL training graphs.

Sv: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By mellanpotential - 14-05-2025 16:07

stars below and maxings looking really great. the 1s and 2s next to/above attributes are decent and it takes a while to get used to. maybe the 1s and 2s should be in green and red to be more clearstars below and maxings looking really great.
the 1s and 2s next to/above attributes are decent and it takes a while
to get used to.
maybe the 1s and 2s should be in green and red to be more clear

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By doug7887 - 14-05-2025 16:30

[LEGEND]

Please, make It opcional, I dont want to use, I prefer the colore.Please, make It opcional, I dont want to use, I prefer the colore.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By roxana - 14-05-2025 16:30

[MZ]

Excelentă treabă.Excelentă treabă.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By doug7887 - 14-05-2025 16:49

[LEGEND]

To be honest, I think it was a bad change. Why did you spend time and energy on a point in the game that was already solved by the community? Why were the colors removed?To be honest, I think it was a bad change. Why did you spend time and energy on a point in the game that was already solved by the community? Why were the colors removed?

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By danielmenezes - 14-05-2025 17:28

This is a great update. My concern which i dont know if is a bug or not is that i have one spot open to buy a foreigner but since this update is being considered locked,this is a unique situation that i'm experiencing or not?This is a great update.
My concern which i dont know if is a bug or not is that i have one spot open to buy a foreigner but since this update is being considered locked,this is a unique situation that i'm experiencing or not?

Отн: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By ffvilla7 (RA) - 14-05-2025 18:15

[BUL]

+1 The colors was much better.

donalton wrote:

The update looks great! But it would be even better if the classifications kept the traditional colors (H4 in pink, H3 in blue, H/L2 in yellow, and L1 in red) instead of just using numbers (1 for H and 2 for L). Many users are already used to this color scheme through extensions and spreadsheets, which would make it more intuitive to read.

+1 The colors was much better.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By nervous_potato - 14-05-2025 18:39

[U21DOM]

Definitely a bug yes, it's the same for me. But it works if you add a player to the shortlist and bid from there.

danielmenezes wrote:

This is a great update.
My concern which i dont know if is a bug or not is that i have one spot open to buy a foreigner but since this update is being considered locked,this is a unique situation that i'm experiencing or not?

Definitely a bug yes, it's the same for me. But it works if you add a player to the shortlist and bid from there.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By thunderexpress (Crew) - 14-05-2025 19:29

[Crew]
President

We are working on finding a solution to the problem. For the time being, you can shortlist a player and use transfer monitor to place a bid (as nervous_potato mentioned). We are sorry for the inconvenience.We are working on finding a solution to the problem. For the time being, you can shortlist a player and use transfer monitor to place a bid (as nervous_potato mentioned). We are sorry for the inconvenience.

Отн: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By naskoch - 14-05-2025 20:42

[BUL]

+1 The colors was much better.

donalton wrote:

The update looks great! But it would be even better if the classifications kept the traditional colors (H4 in pink, H3 in blue, H/L2 in yellow, and L1 in red) instead of just using numbers (1 for H and 2 for L). Many users are already used to this color scheme through extensions and spreadsheets, which would make it more intuitive to read.

+1 The colors was much better.

Re: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By thunderexpress (Crew) - 14-05-2025 21:03

[Crew]
President

We have released a fix for this problem. Can you please confirm that the problem is now solved? Thank you!We have released a fix for this problem. Can you please confirm that the problem is now solved?

Thank you!

Beantwortet: Discussion on Upcoming Transfer Market update

By bessarion - 14-05-2025 21:26

[BGB]

It's solved 😀. Thank you!It's solved 😀.
Thank you!

Previous

Page 1 2 3

Next