Football » English » ManagerZone talk

Which player would you keep?

By viedras20 - 09-05-2022 21:14

[LT-Cm]

Let's say you have these two players: http://mzplayer.se/?id=0509190950 You need to keep only one of them. Which one would it be?Let's say you have these two players: http://mzplayer.se/?id=0509190950

You need to keep only one of them. Which one would it be?

 

Page 1

 

Reply

Last Message

Re: Which player would you keep?

By disinocht - 09-05-2022 23:25

[204]
President

I'd keep Player2. More play intelligence, more experience, more valuable. The 10 in ball control is not enough to justify the low play intelligence.I'd keep Player2. More play intelligence, more experience, more valuable.

The 10 in ball control is not enough to justify the low play intelligence.

Re: Which player would you keep?

By k33n3y - 10-05-2022 00:36

The exp is irrelevant in theory unless you need him right now to perform. Player 1 will hit the same exp in 2 years. So it's basically a toss up between whether you feel BC or PI is more required. If you play SP I'd go BC personally but I know some people prioritise PI in defenders as its more valuable on the market from what I can see. So if you want a big load of change now. Sell player 2. Keep both potentially?The exp is irrelevant in theory unless you need him right now to perform.

Player 1 will hit the same exp in 2 years.

So it's basically a toss up between whether you feel BC or PI is more required.

If you play SP I'd go BC personally but I know some people prioritise PI in defenders as its more valuable on the market from what I can see.

So if you want a big load of change now. Sell player 2.

Keep both potentially?

Re: Which player would you keep?

By k33n3y - 10-05-2022 00:37

They're both 49/60 from their main skills. Which is very very good imo. That's if you play SP and you're a fan of the moneyball movie hahaThey're both 49/60 from their main skills. Which is very very good imo.

That's if you play SP and you're a fan of the moneyball movie haha

Re: Which player would you keep?

By douglaskampl - 10-05-2022 03:51

[BRAU18]
President

22

Re: Which player would you keep?

By rockstarroberts - 10-05-2022 04:40

player 2 is a defender and player 1 is a midfielder. It depends on if you need a defender or midfielder more at the momentplayer 2 is a defender and player 1 is a midfielder. It depends on if you need a defender or midfielder more at the moment

Re: Which player would you keep?

By evosa - 10-05-2022 08:20

[LEGEND]

I would keep player2. Player1 lacks play int. to play on top level.I would keep player2. Player1 lacks play int. to play on top level.

Re: Which player would you keep?

By viedras20 - 10-05-2022 12:17

[LT-Cm]

Thank you all for your input!Thank you all for your input!

Sv: Which player would you keep?

By freddemand - 10-05-2022 15:48

[TDF]

Player 2 here too. For reasons of PI mentioned above.Player 2 here too. For reasons of PI mentioned above.

Re: Which player would you keep?

By ashleyhughes - 11-05-2022 01:08

[LEGEND]

Player 2 for better PI and experience.Player 2 for better PI and experience.

Re: Which player would you keep?

By viedras20 - 07-06-2022 15:13

[LT-Cm]

After all, I am going to sell both of them, in case anyone is interested :)After all, I am going to sell both of them, in case anyone is interested :)

Re: Which player would you keep?

By jere92 - 08-06-2022 01:13

What brought you into this decision is my curiosity?What brought you into this decision is my curiosity?

Re: Which player would you keep?

By viedras20 - 08-06-2022 13:43

[LT-Cm]

Have some better options instead of them :) I liked the one with 8 PI, but I prefer to have defenders with 10 in defense, while for midfielders I chose to keep others that have higher speed, BC and AP, even though they have 8 in tackling.Have some better options instead of them :) I liked the one with 8 PI, but I prefer to have defenders with 10 in defense, while for midfielders I chose to keep others that have higher speed, BC and AP, even though they have 8 in tackling.

Re: Which player would you keep?

By dougjudy - 13-06-2022 20:48

PLayer 2. Player 1 sucksPLayer 2. Player 1 sucks

Re: Which player would you keep?

By kray - 10-09-2022 13:18

Player 2Player 2

Re: Which player would you keep?

By haoyuan - 31-08-2023 21:36

[World]

i'll keep player 2. just imagine I have this player and i just drill him in shooting everyday. he might become a nightmare of the opponent's defense. just kiddingi'll keep player 2. just imagine I have this player and i just drill him in shooting everyday. he might become a nightmare of the opponent's defense. just kidding

 

Page 1