Football » English » ManagerZone talk

Keeping Crisis

By dwhwanderers - 25-01-2021 10:17

I don't really play anywhere near as much as I did so have lost the way. I have these 2 GK's question is which one do i keep and play, Adcock still has potential, Nathan has the skills, without the nasty Stamina maxing no way I would consider losing him but he does have really hi PI, does that compensate for stamina, does stamina even matter in a GK? Ive seen these questions posted on this very board many times over the years but wondered what todays opinions was http://mzplayer.se/?id=0125092682 Any thoughts greatly received thanks allI don't really play anywhere near as much as I did so have lost the way. I have these 2 GK's question is which one do i keep and play, Adcock still has potential, Nathan has the skills, without the nasty Stamina maxing no way I would consider losing him but he does have really hi PI, does that compensate for stamina, does stamina even matter in a GK? Ive seen these questions posted on this very board many times over the years but wondered what todays opinions was

http://mzplayer.se/?id=0125092682

Any thoughts greatly received

thanks all

 

Page 1

 

Reply

Last Message

Re: Keeping Crisis

By chucky06 - 25-01-2021 10:59

[AUSNZ]
President

Stamina definitely matter. Probably the second most important skill after keeping or at least in the top 3. Depends on the potential HP and LP of Adcock I’d sell both a buy a keeper that’s better than adcock but more potential and balls. Answer to your question is I’d still play your older keeper right now though as he has far superior balls but long term he’s not a good optionStamina definitely matter. Probably the second most important skill after keeping or at least in the top 3.

Depends on the potential HP and LP of Adcock I’d sell both a buy a keeper that’s better than adcock but more potential and balls.

Answer to your question is I’d still play your older keeper right now though as he has far superior balls but long term he’s not a good option

Re: Keeping Crisis

By horas (FA) - 25-01-2021 13:22

[LT-Cm]
President

I have to agree stamina I would say is the number 2 skill for keeper, third would be the play inteligence.I have to agree stamina I would say is the number 2 skill for keeper, third would be the play inteligence.

Re: Keeping Crisis

By evosa - 25-01-2021 14:37

[LEGEND]

Lately I have started to think quite opposite actually - but I haven't had time to actually test this somehow. Because sometimes speed and stamina seem quite pointless for keepers.. could you substantiate your argument?

chucky06 wrote:

Stamina definitely matter.

Lately I have started to think quite opposite actually - but I haven't had time to actually test this somehow. Because sometimes speed and stamina seem quite pointless for keepers..

could you substantiate your argument?

Re: Keeping Crisis

By dwhwanderers - 25-01-2021 16:13

Thanks all, that was my thinking, why would a GK need stamina if he doesnt move?Thanks all, that was my thinking, why would a GK need stamina if he doesnt move?

Re: Keeping Crisis

By horas (FA) - 25-01-2021 18:12

[LT-Cm]
President

hahah :) doing nothing also is hard :)hahah :) doing nothing also is hard :)

Re: Keeping Crisis

By charef (FA) (NC) - 25-01-2021 21:16

[PV]

I do think that speed is pointless.

evosa wrote:

Lately I have started to think quite opposite actually - but I haven't had time to actually test this somehow. Because sometimes speed and stamina seem quite pointless for keepers..

could you substantiate your argument?

I do think that speed is pointless.

Re: Keeping Crisis

By horas (FA) - 25-01-2021 21:44

[LT-Cm]
President

I agree about the speed regarding the keepers and I will add that I think speed for striker if you play wings is also pointless.I agree about the speed regarding the keepers and I will add that I think speed for striker if you play wings is also pointless.

Απ: Keeping Crisis

By birginia (NC) - 25-01-2021 22:20

[Greece]
President

I have test lot of keepers all these years! When i win 5 times in a row champions cup titles and lot of other titles i have super keepers all the way and i think this was the most important that helps me win all these seasons! my opinion is that after keeping (of course) the most important is play intelligence stamina ball control cross balls and after this is speed set plays (some users thinks that lot of set plays helps to save penalties i am not sure)! But its so difficult to find keeper with 10-10-10 (keeping-stamina-play intelligence) and if you find you must pay crazy money to buy him! For your question i will sell them both and try to find a keeper like the first one you send with more stamina and some other balls! Hope to help you!I have test lot of keepers all these years! When i win 5 times in a row champions cup titles and lot of other titles i have super keepers all the way and i think this was the most important that helps me win all these seasons! my opinion is that after keeping (of course) the most important is play intelligence stamina ball control cross balls and after this is speed set plays (some users thinks that lot of set plays helps to save penalties i am not sure)! But its so difficult to find keeper with 10-10-10 (keeping-stamina-play intelligence) and if you find you must pay crazy money to buy him! For your question i will sell them both and try to find a keeper like the first one you send with more stamina and some other balls! Hope to help you!

Re: Keeping Crisis

By horas (FA) - 26-01-2021 21:30

[LT-Cm]
President

I am growing the keeper which is 10 keep will be 10 PI ant minimum 8-10 stamina😁I am growing the keeper which is 10 keep will be 10 PI ant minimum 8-10 stamina😁

Re: Keeping Crisis

By doug7887 - 27-01-2021 14:17

[LEGEND]

In my expirience with U-23 I see that a minimum of 6 on stamina works ok, but Intel I would say that a minimum of 8 is necessary and about speed, I think this is not so important for keepers, I prefer Ball Control, Long Pass and Set play instead.In my expirience with U-23 I see that a minimum of 6 on stamina works ok, but Intel I would say that a minimum of 8 is necessary and about speed, I think this is not so important for keepers, I prefer Ball Control, Long Pass and Set play instead.

Απ: Keeping Crisis

By birginia (NC) - 27-01-2021 15:48

[Greece]
President

Share to see him my friend! and also tell us his stars!

horas wrote:

I am growing the keeper which is 10 keep will be 10 PI ant minimum 8-10 stamina😁

Share to see him my friend! and also tell us his stars!

Re: Keeping Crisis

By franella82 - 03-02-2021 13:26

[CBA-MZ]

I compared top keepers several times. Stamina and speed higher than 5 seems to be enough to a good keeper, below these values in either of the two skills goalkeepers often cause some unexpected negative scores. Always talking about keepers with 9 or 10 intelligence and 10 experience.

evosa wrote:

Lately I have started to think quite opposite actually - but I haven't had time to actually test this somehow. Because sometimes speed and stamina seem quite pointless for keepers..

could you substantiate your argument?

I compared top keepers several times.

Stamina and speed higher than 5 seems to be enough to a good keeper, below these values in either of the two skills goalkeepers often cause some unexpected negative scores. Always talking about keepers with 9 or 10 intelligence and 10 experience.

Re: Keeping Crisis

By horas (FA) - 03-02-2021 14:21

[LT-Cm]
President

[fpl=210947935] HP 4 stars Keep and PI, maxings for now only the keeping all other skills are still training :)

Mindaugas Karalius

Age: 35

HP 4 stars Keep and PI, maxings for now only the keeping all other skills are still training :)

Edited: 03-02-2021 14:21
Total edits: 1

Re: Keeping Crisis

By horas (FA) - 03-02-2021 14:22

[LT-Cm]
President

and I Will mention that I bought him for 600 K :)and I Will mention that I bought him for 600 K :)

Re: Keeping Crisis

By chucky06 - 03-02-2021 14:55

[AUSNZ]
President

He’s very underdeveloped but he might eventually be a decent keeperHe’s very underdeveloped but he might eventually be a decent keeper

 

Page 1