drieet wrote:I like the new feature as I like puzzles + the community seems to be alive again 
I don't think any of the theories here are accurate and I actually think we will only see things clear when players are older and more developed. I don't believe that the Crew would create a system wherin once you get it, you can fully predict a player in 4 skills.
I have some ideas regarding how the system would work, but have just 1 question I hope the crew will answer: Is the scout always right? Or is there a sort of random factor? Is it for example possible that a 3 star player is rated as a 4 star player by the scout?
This would overcomplicate things, but would be nice to know that because with possible mistakes, we should not take outliers into account.
I'm on the phone most of my time, and it's hard for me to make printscreens, but all my scout reports were accurate for both sports.
HP and LP were accurate.
I think Darkline was very unlucky.
If he got 2 stars LPs on other skills than stamina, which maxed at 6, it's obvious for me that those two LP skills will max at 5 6 or 6 6, because they are rated 2*.
If they would have been rated as 1*, they probably max at 4-5, maybe 6.
From what I saw, the difference between 4*HP and 3*HP is that 4* guarantees you a 10 with probability of minimum 9 maximum 10, while 3*HP has a minimum 9 9 or 10 8. So, with 3*HP you have a 50‰ chance of having at least one 10 skill, and a good chance of having 10 9 on those 2 skills.
Most of the players, and I mean more than 57% of them are worthless.
We know now for a fact.
I have exhausted my Youth Exchange possibilities for both sports and still end up with a lot of 2*HP youths.
2*HP youths on speed/stamina and control is ok.
I know that they will become useful players, having 8 or maximum 9 on those 2 attributes.
The worst thing that can happen is to max at 8 7and the best thing would be to max at 9 8.
What this new feature did was to help us get rid of all useless youths, which is like +57% of them, and that is a great thing.
Also, the youth exchange possibility will become a must for everybody.
From now on, every Tuesday we will start looking for young talents to bring to the club and exchange our current 2 stars players with 3 stars or 4 stars.
This is called real scouting IMO.
The worst part of this scouting are the LP skills.
As seen, 2*LP means 6 5 minimum and maybe 7 7 maximum, but I doubt they will be so high. Probably most of them will be in the average of 6 6 or 7 5.
Also as seen, 1*LP means 4 4 minimum and 5 5 or 7 4 maximum. Probably most of them will be in the average of 5 5 or 4 6.
That's all the conclusions I came up with so far.
I promise to tell you if I find anything else.
For me it's a great job done by the Crew. I won't train youths so blindly from now on, with so high expectations and so poor results or bad disappointments.
Now we will see the players how they really are.
Probably, it was a shock for many managers to see how many bad prospects we really have.
Of course many of us hoped so much more for our young, still green, players.
I wish you all the best.
Best regards.