Football » English » Suggestions/Improvements

Lower the youth age to 14

By scruttino - 18-06-2017 03:09

[AUSNZ]

It's radical I know. But nothing else would change. You just have 2 extra seasons to develop players as youths.It's radical I know.

But nothing else would change.

You just have 2 extra seasons to develop players as youths.

 

Page 1

 

Reply

Last Message

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By aemi - 18-06-2017 07:24

[Canada]

In my country, 16 is still the age to consent. "Age of consent law in Canada refers to cultural and legal discussions in Canada regarding the age of consent, which was raised from 14 to 16 in May 2008 as part of the Tackling Violent Crime Act." If a youth can't consent to became a player to my club under the law, he's useless to me. Can you spot any kangaroos don where you are?In my country, 16 is still the age to consent.

"Age of consent law in Canada refers to cultural and legal discussions in Canada regarding the age of consent, which was raised from 14 to 16 in May 2008 as part of the Tackling Violent Crime Act."

If a youth can't consent to became a player to my club under the law, he's useless to me.

Can you spot any kangaroos don where you are?

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By evosa - 18-06-2017 12:04

[LEGEND]

Why? Whats wrong with current system?

scruttino wrote:

It's radical I know.

But nothing else would change.

You just have 2 extra seasons to develop players as youths.

Why? Whats wrong with current system?

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By scruttino - 18-06-2017 14:25

[AUSNZ]

It would lower the cost of developing players In real football, players don't arrive at professional club as if it's the first time they've ever kicked a football, so this would allow you more time to train them earlier Should a player show real talent quickly they could realistically make the first team, ie seniors, around the age of 21 It would open up the possibility of an U18 international world cup It would widen the premiership window for how long your senior team is competitive before players start deteriorating It would lessen the impact of players being underdeveloped because people are constantly on selling talented Uxx players and not developing them properly, because you'll have then longer as youths without being able to sell themIt would lower the cost of developing players

In real football, players don't arrive at professional club as if it's the first time they've ever kicked a football, so this would allow you more time to train them earlier

Should a player show real talent quickly they could realistically make the first team, ie seniors, around the age of 21

It would open up the possibility of an U18 international world cup

It would widen the premiership window for how long your senior team is competitive before players start deteriorating

It would lessen the impact of players being underdeveloped because people are constantly on selling talented Uxx players and not developing them properly, because you'll have then longer as youths without being able to sell them

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By dowopado - 18-06-2017 18:18

[BotP]

Radical idea...but why not. Judging from the skills 16 year olds come into the academy with in MZ, I think those skills are more suitable to 14 year olds.Radical idea...but why not. Judging from the skills 16 year olds come into the academy with in MZ, I think those skills are more suitable to 14 year olds.

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By aldebaran - 18-06-2017 21:13

and what will happen in the future when you have a bunch of 25/26 yo maxed in every skill (besides set plays/heading/keeping) ? the u18 nations cup sounds interesting, but what about the youth exchange programme? what will happen if someone decides to exchange a national u18 player? the NT will end up missing players? or the manager of the team will be forced to keep the youth he doesn't want for a full season (or whatever the time limit will be for the u18 nationals to be *unflagged* as nationals in order for them to exchangeable? don't think there's a viable option here (regarding the cup)and what will happen in the future when you have a bunch of 25/26 yo maxed in every skill (besides set plays/heading/keeping)

?

the u18 nations cup sounds interesting, but what about the youth exchange programme? what will happen if someone decides to exchange a national u18 player?

the NT will end up missing players? or the manager of the team will be forced to keep the youth he doesn't want for a full season (or whatever the time limit will be for the u18 nationals to be *unflagged* as nationals in order for them to exchangeable?

don't think there's a viable option here (regarding the cup)

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By aldebaran - 18-06-2017 21:14

*to be exchangeable*to be exchangeable

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By aemi - 18-06-2017 21:41

[Canada]

I will only support this magnificent idea if the youths come with their diaper bag at no cost to our club.I will only support this magnificent idea if the youths come with their diaper bag at no cost to our club.

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By scruttino - 18-06-2017 23:49

[AUSNZ]

I would prefer that was the case. Plus it opens up future game development opportunities for adding new skills

aldebaran wrote:

and what will happen in the future when you have a bunch of 25/26 yo maxed in every skill (besides set plays/heading/keeping

I would prefer that was the case. Plus it opens up future game development opportunities for adding new skills

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By scruttino - 18-06-2017 23:51

[AUSNZ]

If a player gets exchanged you lose them from the team. Simple

aldebaran wrote:

the u18 nations cup sounds interesting, but what about the youth exchange programme? what will happen if someone decides to exchange a national u18 player?

the NT will end up missing players? or the manager of the team will be forced to keep the youth he doesn't want for a full season (or whatever the time limit will be for the u18 nationals to be *unflagged* as nationals in order for them to exchangeable?

don't think there's a viable option here (regarding the cup)

If a player gets exchanged you lose them from the team. Simple

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By aldebaran - 19-06-2017 08:42

fair enough, but correct If I'm mistaken (since you're NT) the NT roster gets "locked" before the tournament starts, right? what will happen if lets say 15 out of the 30 (no idea what the max number of players in the NT roster is) NT u18 players get exchanged in the same day? and what will happen if 10 out of the 15 get exchanged the next week? The problem is that (at least that's what I believe) crew would be more than happy to implement something that follows the current setup of the game and doesn't cause problemsfair enough, but correct If I'm mistaken (since you're NT)

the NT roster gets "locked" before the tournament starts, right?
what will happen if lets say 15 out of the 30 (no idea what the max number of players in the NT roster is) NT u18 players get exchanged in the same day? and what will happen if 10 out of the 15 get exchanged the next week?

The problem is that (at least that's what I believe) crew would be more than happy to implement something that follows the current setup of the game and doesn't cause problems

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By scruttino - 19-06-2017 09:11

[AUSNZ]

I'm not sure on the exact rules of how the NT player lock and youth exchanges would work. But it's an idea to think on

aldebaran wrote:

fair enough, but correct If I'm mistaken (since you're NT)

the NT roster gets "locked" before the tournament starts, right?
what will happen if lets say 15 out of the 30 (no idea what the max number of players in the NT roster is) NT u18 players get exchanged in the same day? and what will happen if 10 out of the 15 get exchanged the next week?

The problem is that (at least that's what I believe) crew would be more than happy to implement something that follows the current setup of the game and doesn't cause problems

I'm not sure on the exact rules of how the NT player lock and youth exchanges would work. But it's an idea to think on

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By aldebaran - 19-06-2017 09:50

sorry about the "incomplete" post....I have a 2 year old daredevil in the house :P The problem is that (at least that's what I believe) crew would be more than happy to implement something that follows the current setup of the game and doesn't cause problems, but won't try to implement something that requires new code/rewriting rules/or whatever else might cause instability or a new setup/new rules etc etc cause if they didn't had any problems, then all those years we'd have a new sim engine and not constantly patching up the old one. not to mention more serious problems (marketability wise) like the 3d/analyzer not working anymore with the latest versions of certain browsers...sorry about the "incomplete" post....I have a 2 year old daredevil in the house :P

The problem is that (at least that's what I believe) crew would be more than happy to implement something that follows the current setup of the game and doesn't cause problems, but won't try to implement something that requires new code/rewriting rules/or whatever else might cause instability or a new setup/new rules etc etc

cause if they didn't had any problems, then all those years we'd have a new sim engine and not constantly patching up the old one. not to mention more serious problems (marketability wise) like the 3d/analyzer not working anymore with the latest versions of certain browsers...

Re: Lower the youth age to 14

By scruttino - 19-06-2017 11:36

[AUSNZ]

I'd be fine with whichever one overruled the other. NT managers would adapt either wayI'd be fine with whichever one overruled the other. NT managers would adapt either way

 

Page 1