Football » English » Suggestions/Improvements

Naturalized players

By kingjose - 16-02-2017 23:16

[FLUSA]

Hello. I would like to suggest something. As a lot of you know sometimes players in real life get citizenship from a country that they were not born in. Once this players are naturalized they can play for the national team of that country or both. My suggestion is to let players that have a visa for a country that they are not from to play for the national team of that country. Or after a certain time let them get both citizenship and again, let him play for both countries. To simplify it, basically this: If a player from X country plays in XX country and gets naturalized(or a visa) he is eligible to play for the national team of XX. I believe doing this will help countries with fewer members to be competitive with the ones with more members. What do you guys think?Hello. I would like to suggest something. As a lot of you know sometimes players in real life get citizenship from a country that they were not born in. Once this players are naturalized they can play for the national team of that country or both. My suggestion is to let players that have a visa for a country that they are not from to play for the national team of that country. Or after a certain time let them get both citizenship and again, let him play for both countries.

To simplify it, basically this: If a player from X country plays in XX country and gets naturalized(or a visa) he is eligible to play for the national team of XX.

I believe doing this will help countries with fewer members to be competitive with the ones with more members.

What do you guys think?

 

Page 1

 

Reply

Last Message

Re: Naturalized players

By maria171 - 17-02-2017 17:03

[MAS]
President

Absolutely agree with this idea. But, it will be better to let the player represent for one country only instead of both to avoid other problem. Anyway, a great idea that surely will help other country that have a lower userbase such as mine.Absolutely agree with this idea. But, it will be better to let the player represent for one country only instead of both to avoid other problem. Anyway, a great idea that surely will help other country that have a lower userbase such as mine.

Re: Naturalized players

By kingjose - 17-02-2017 18:23

[FLUSA]

Well, I know some players(not personally) in real life play for 2 countries. It depends if the player wants to go and represent the country he most likes/wants. But is not like we can ask the player so I would suggest letting the player play for both countries except once he gets called for lets say, the U.S. in the world cup, he cannot represent Mexico in the world cups but is eligible to represent Mexico in the next world cup or something similar like that. Also, if the idea is not well liked or it cannot be done, let the decision fall on the owner of the player; for him to decide which country the player will represent if he gets called for both.Well, I know some players(not personally) in real life play for 2 countries. It depends if the player wants to go and represent the country he most likes/wants. But is not like we can ask the player so I would suggest letting the player play for both countries except once he gets called for lets say, the U.S. in the world cup, he cannot represent Mexico in the world cups but is eligible to represent Mexico in the next world cup or something similar like that.

Also, if the idea is not well liked or it cannot be done, let the decision fall on the owner of the player; for him to decide which country the player will represent if he gets called for both.

Re: Naturalized players

By sbrownridge - 17-02-2017 23:56

[Canada]

A Mexican playing for team USA? Haven't you been listening to the giant Cheetos mascot that's running 'muricah?A Mexican playing for team USA?

Haven't you been listening to the giant Cheetos mascot that's running 'muricah?

Re: Naturalized players

By kingjose - 18-02-2017 01:30

[FLUSA]

A wild leaf appeared. And it's ok. Mexican-American players have played in the U.S. national soccer team in RL. It was an example that I gave just for explaining. If you want I can say: " But is not like we can ask the player so I would suggest letting the player play for both countries except once he gets called for lets say, England in the world cup, he cannot represent Ireland in the world cup but is eligible to represent Ireland in the next world cup or something similar like that."A wild leaf appeared. And it's ok. Mexican-American players have played in the U.S. national soccer team in RL. It was an example that I gave just for explaining. If you want I can say:
" But is not like we can ask the player so I would suggest letting the player play for both countries except once he gets called for lets say, England in the world cup, he cannot represent Ireland in the world cup but is eligible to represent Ireland in the next world cup or something similar like that."

Re: Naturalized players

By thrillaz-fc - 18-02-2017 08:09

[BotP]

Sounds Like a Good Idea that Could Work, Call them Foreign Internationals or Dual Citizen's and Let them Play for only their 2nd National Team but Eligible too play in Both Countries without being Classified as Foreign in their Nations and 2nd Countries League!!! Also too Stop any Unfair Advantages and Cheating or Arguments/Disputes, the Player chosen for the 2nd National Team After Playin so Long in Another Foreign League should Have the Full Consent from his Nations Manager 1st too Know he Wont Be in His Squad Plans IMO that should be the Law too Settle it, But Never Can The Player Switch Nations Again Unless he's only Played in the U21 National Side like in Real Life!!! Simples :)Sounds Like a Good Idea that Could Work, Call them Foreign Internationals or Dual Citizen's and Let them Play for only their 2nd National Team but Eligible too play in Both Countries without being Classified as Foreign in their Nations and 2nd Countries League!!! Also too Stop any Unfair Advantages and Cheating or Arguments/Disputes, the Player chosen for the 2nd National Team After Playin so Long in Another Foreign League should Have the Full Consent from his Nations Manager 1st too Know he Wont Be in His Squad Plans IMO that should be the Law too Settle it, But Never Can The Player Switch Nations Again Unless he's only Played in the U21 National Side like in Real Life!!! Simples :)

Re: Naturalized players

By kingjose - 18-02-2017 08:45

[FLUSA]

Right right but I still think that the choice or the one in charge of letting the player play for X team or XX team should be the manager(owner) of the player since in real life the player will choose but here, to make it that after he gets the dual citizenship he cannot play for X country and only XX country without "giving him a choice" wouldn't be fair. In my opinion.Right right but I still think that the choice or the one in charge of letting the player play for X team or XX team should be the manager(owner) of the player since in real life the player will choose but here, to make it that after he gets the dual citizenship he cannot play for X country and only XX country without "giving him a choice" wouldn't be fair. In my opinion.

Re: Naturalized players

By thrillaz-fc - 18-02-2017 15:17

[BotP]

Wouldn't be Right too Have them Playin for 2 Senior National Teams, It shouldn't be up too the Owner off the Player but the National Managers should Decide and once the Decision is Made, that be the Only Country he can Represent!!! In Real Life He Wouldn't Have a Choice Anyway, as Players Usually Turn too Play for Other Countries When they Know their Not Good Enough for their Original National Side!!! That should be the Same Case Scenario Here, it Shouldn't be up too the Players Team Owner.Wouldn't be Right too Have them Playin for 2 Senior National Teams, It shouldn't be up too the Owner off the Player but the National Managers should Decide and once the Decision is Made, that be the Only Country he can Represent!!! In Real Life He Wouldn't Have a Choice Anyway, as Players Usually Turn too Play for Other Countries When they Know their Not Good Enough for their Original National Side!!! That should be the Same Case Scenario Here, it Shouldn't be up too the Players Team Owner.

Re: Naturalized players

By kingjose - 18-02-2017 17:58

[FLUSA]

Well I am not calling a liar, and I am not an expert about real life National Teams but I do know some players in real life(not personally) were eligible to play for two countries. An example would be Jack Grealish, he was eligible to play for Ireland and England and he choose to play for England. José María Basanta is an Argentine born Mexican and as soon as he got his Mexican citizenship Argentina called him for their squad, and he ended up deciding to play for Argentina. So yes, I still believe that it i would be the choice of the manager to decide but at the end of the day, it would be crew's decision if they decide to add this feature.Well I am not calling a liar, and I am not an expert about real life National Teams but I do know some players in real life(not personally) were eligible to play for two countries. An example would be Jack Grealish, he was eligible to play for Ireland and England and he choose to play for England. José María Basanta is an Argentine born Mexican and as soon as he got his Mexican citizenship Argentina called him for their squad, and he ended up deciding to play for Argentina. So yes, I still believe that it i would be the choice of the manager to decide but at the end of the day, it would be crew's decision if they decide to add this feature.

Re: Naturalized players

By aemi - 19-02-2017 03:51

[Canada]

Excuses, sounds like something a city fan would say lol For everyone else, I'm joking btw

maria171 wrote:

Anyway, a great idea that surely will help other country that have a lower userbase such as mine.

Excuses, sounds like something a city fan would say lol

For everyone else, I'm joking btw

Re: Naturalized players

By kingjose - 19-02-2017 06:01

[FLUSA]

I know when someone is joking. I was too :} What I want to know is what do you think of this idea or if you want to add something to it?

aemi wrote:

Excuses, sounds like something a city fan would say lol

For everyone else, I'm joking btw

I know when someone is joking. I was too :}

What I want to know is what do you think of this idea or if you want to add something to it?

Re: Naturalized players

By scruttino - 19-02-2017 16:07

[AUSNZ]

It depends if a country with low users would select a player at an earlier age than when he would get selected for his birth country. If so, then the idea is extremely problematic. I've no problem with players that wouldn't make a national team playing for another country. But I know that I would be looking for the best talent I can find and add them to the squad as soon as possible to stop the other country selecting said player. Think of it from an U/21 set-up point of view, I'm not sure it would work as it wouldn't if it's a first come first served rule.It depends if a country with low users would select a player at an earlier age than when he would get selected for his birth country.

If so, then the idea is extremely problematic. I've no problem with players that wouldn't make a national team playing for another country. But I know that I would be looking for the best talent I can find and add them to the squad as soon as possible to stop the other country selecting said player.

Think of it from an U/21 set-up point of view, I'm not sure it would work as it wouldn't if it's a first come first served rule.

Re: Naturalized players

By kingjose - 19-02-2017 21:03

[FLUSA]

That's why I said that the player could play for X team for a tournament and if he get called for another tournament by XX team he can play for that one. Or let the manager decide which NT he plays for if the player gets called by both of them.That's why I said that the player could play for X team for a tournament and if he get called for another tournament by XX team he can play for that one. Or let the manager decide which NT he plays for if the player gets called by both of them.

Re: Naturalized players

By azkaban-za - 16-11-2017 02:13

[ᴀғяιcᴀ]
President

+1+1

 

Page 1